Florida cuisine is all about fresh flavors, colorful plating, and vibrant meals that make you want to keep splashing in the ocean—which you’ll find all of at the best seafood restaurants in St. Augustine. Much of the culinary world in St. Augustine is influenced by Latin and Caribbean cultures, as well as Southern comfort dishes paired with the fresh, local ingredients of our tropical bounty. You’ll find a lot of fish, citrus, and fruit on the menus at the local eateries.
One of the all-time best seafood restaurants in St. Augustine is Collage Restaurant, which also happens to be one of the most romantic restaurants for celebrations or date nights. At Collage, they use fish from local waters and produce from nearby farms whenever possible, and everything is scratch-made in-house. Popular seafood options include the catch of the day, grouper filet, scallops, and shrimp dishes.
Many of the best seafood restaurants in St. Augustine are within walking distance from our romantic bed and breakfast. There’s no better way than to set out on foot and explore the old cobblestone streets of the historic downtown. The Nation’s Oldest City is full of great things for couples to do—whether that’s spending time on the beach, dining out, or just spending quiet time in your guest room at our cozy B&B. Book your lodging in St. Augustine today!
The Best Seafood Restaurants in St. Augustine, Florida
Dining out is such a fun part of any vacation, discovering hidden gems, new ingredients, and intriguing preparations. The best seafood restaurants in St. Augustine offer all the above, as well as fantastic hospitality and incredible atmospheres for a relaxing evening with delectable dishes, craft cocktails, and more.
Here are the best seafood restaurants in St. Augustine:
- Harry’s Seafood: The menu here blends Southern, Cajun, and Creole flavors. Guests can enjoy a variety of seafood dishes, such as shrimp and scallop Orleans, Bourbon Street salmon, and the famous Harry’s signature crab cakes. There are also non-seafood options like the French market pasta and Southern fried chicken.
- Collage Restaurant: Consistently ranked as one of the most romantic restaurants in St. Augustine, we always recommend this spot for a lovely dinner of fresh seafood, hearty entrees, and beautiful appetizers.
- River & Fort: This elegant restaurant is directly across from the Castillo de San Marcos and offers magnificent views from its rooftop. Seafood fans will want to opt for the Grand Platter, which includes lobster, fresh-shucked oysters, King crab, and more.
- Llama Restaurant: One of the newest restaurants in St. Augustine, this Peruvian spot has made quite a splash! They have an impressive selection of ceviche with different seafood options, as well as a spectacular surf and turf.
- Forgotten Tonic: One of our favorite places is Forgotten Tonic, a cozy neighborhood spot off the beaten path offering innovative drinks and menu items. You can’t go wrong with the fresh catch of the day or the popular shrimp and grits etouffee.
- O.C. White’s Seafood: This popular mainstay is located in the historic Worth House circa 1790. It offers cozy indoor dining as well as lovely outdoor patio seating. The menu leans Southern with Cajun influences, including shrimp & grits and blue crab cakes.
- Cap’s on the Water: Known for its scratch-made margaritas, locally famous crab cakes, and stunning sunset views, Cap’s on the Water is a must for seafood lovers! There is fantastic seating indoors and out, all with spectacular water vistas.
- St. Augustine Fish House: Enjoy the spacious outdoor deck, often with live music, craft cocktails, and spectacular seafood dishes. The fish options range from grilled salmon and trout to seared tuna and peel-and-eat shrimp.
Your Romantic Getaway Awaits at our St. Augustine Bed and Breakfast
There’s something special about choosing a small, locally owned property as your lodging on a romantic getaway in Florida. There are no cookie-cutter rooms and no impersonal service. At Casa de Sueños, we only have seven elegant and beautifully appointed rooms, so our Innkeepers can offer attentive hospitality and ensure that each guest is having the best time in St. Augustine. There are shared spaces to interact with other like-minded guests if you so choose.
Your private suite, designed with couples in mind, offers the perfect reprieve. Guest rooms have lush linens, fluffy towels, plush robes, and comfortable beds. Each has a pristine en suite bathroom—some with jetted soaking tubs for two—and the perfect place to unwind after a day of adventure in St. Augustine. As an adults-only lodging property, you’ll never encounter unwanted noise or crowds—you may even feel as though you have the whole place to yourself.
Another perk of choosing our St. Augustine bed and breakfast is the long list of included amenities. Of course, you’ll have a deliciously homemade breakfast each morning with sweet and savory entrees and all the accouterments. But then we’ll also treat you to an afternoon social hour with snacks, beer, and wine, which is the perfect start before heading out to dinner at one of the best seafood restaurants in town. We can’t wait to host you; book your lodging in St. Augustine today!
